Stop-And-Frisk Program: NY Federal Appeals Court Ruling Blocked As Judge Scheindlin Removed From Case (Video)

By

A New York federal appeals court blocked Judge Shira Scheindlin's orders from August, which would have required changes to the New York Police Department's stop-and-frisk program, The Associated Press reported.

Scheindlin, who deemed the police program unconstitutional for routinely stopping and questioning people of color, was also removed from the case on Thursday.

The ruling was "praised by police unions, Republican mayoral candidate Joe Lhota and the Bloomberg administration, which asked for the stay and has long criticized Scheindlin, saying she endangered public safety with an anti-police mindset," Newsday reported.

After Scheindlin's ruling in August, the city appealed her findings and her remedial orders, which would have included monitoring and tracking officers, The AP reported.

The appeals court said her removal was necessary "because she ran afoul of the code of conduct for U.S. judges by compromising the necessity for a judge to avoid the appearance of partiality in part because of a series of media interviews and public statements responding publicly to criticism of the court," The AP also reported.

Judge Scheindlin went as far as saying that New York police officers specifically targeted black and Hispanic men.

Mayor Michael Bloomberg blasted the judge's ruling in August, calling it "a dangerous decision made by a judge who... does not understand how policing works and what is compliant with the U.S. Constitution as determined by the Supreme Court... Crime can come back any time the criminals think they can get away with things. We just cannot let that happen," he said.

The NYPD feels a sense of vindication, believing that making changes to the the stop-and-frisk program could make the city much more dangerous. Crime has severely reduced in the city since the program was enacted.

Tags
New York City News, Federal Appeals Court

© 2025 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More News
Florida Man Who Allegedly Terrorized Pregnant Girlfriend Sent Her Photos

Florida Man Who Allegedly Terrorized Pregnant Girlfriend Sent Her Photos of Her Toddlers Beaten After She Escaped: Police

Police Chief Spiked Officers' Coffee With Viagra, Left Body Hair

Police Chief Terrorized Staff by Pooping on the Floor, Spiking Coffee with Viagra and Sprinkling Body Hair on Food: Complaint

Texas Man Rammed Parked Tesla

Texas Man Rammed ATV Into Parked Tesla 'at Full Speed,' Keyed 'Elon' Into Side of Others: Police

Dumpster Diving Pedo_03282025_1

Binders of Child Porn Discovered in Dumpster by Homeless Duo Leads Man to Admit to Molesting Dozens of Children: Police