Veteran Turned OnlyFans Model Lured Her Alleged Rapist Into Woods Before Killing Him: Prosecutors

By
Chelsea Denise Perkins
Chelsea Denise Perkins Santa Rosa County Jail

A former Coast Guard member turned OnlyFans model has pleaded guilty to luring a man she once accused of rape into an Ohio national park and fatally shooting him in what prosecutors describe as a calculated act of revenge.

Chelsea Perkins, 35, first reported Matthew Dunmire for rape to Virginia Beach police in 2017, but charges were never filed due to lack of evidence, according to a U.S. Attorney's Office report. Years later, Perkins transitioned into adult entertainment and began using the alias "Selena Savage" on OnlyFans, Cleveland reported.

Despite the unresolved accusation, she reconnected with Dunmire in early 2021 via Facebook. On March 6, 2021, Perkins drove from Virginia to Cleveland, Ohio, where she spent the night with Dunmire in an Airbnb.

The next morning, she took him to the Terra Vista Nature Study Area in Cuyahoga Valley National Park. While hiking, Perkins shot Dunmire once in the back of the head, killing him. Authorities tied her to the scene through GPS, DNA, surveillance footage, and ballistics.

Perkins pleaded guilty on Tuesday, May 27, to second-degree murder and using a firearm during a violent crime. She now faces 20 to 25 years in prison, pending a judge's approval of the plea deal. Sentencing is scheduled for September 9.

Tags
Onlyfans, Murder, Killing, Rape, Shooting

© 2025 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More True Crime
Deana Thetford mugshot

New Mexico Wife Who Said Missing Husband Was 'Fishing' Now Accused of Killing Him and Dragging Body With Tractor

Sarah Grace Patrick mugshot

Georgia Teen Accused of Killing Parents In Their Bed Urged TikTokers to Investigate Murders: 'Would Be a Really Big Hit'

Former MLB Pitcher Guilty of Father-in-Law’s ‘Execution-Style’ Murder

Former MLB Pitcher Guilty of Father-in-Law's 'Execution-Style' Murder

Hershall Creachbaum

'Kidnapped' Ohio Boy With Autism Found Dead Hours Later Was Likely Dead For Weeks, Authorities Say, As Mom Faces Charges