New York Man Set In-Law's House on Fire After Gunning Them Down Alongside Family Dog, Cops Say

A New York man faces murder charges after police say he killed his in-laws and their dogs before setting their home on fire

By
Buda
A New York man faces murder charges after police say he killed his in-laws and their dogs. Dutchess County Sheriff's Office

A New York man is facing murder charges after police say he killed his in-laws and their dogs before setting their home on fire.

Robert J. Buda, 34, faces murder, arson, and animal cruelty charges in the case, according to police. Police were called to the home in Wappinger around 6:30 p.m. on Jan. 26. They found the home engulfed in flames and, after the fire was extinguished, found the bodies of Paul and Jo-Ann Hait, ages 63 and 65, police stated.

Buda was the Hait's son-in-law, News 12 reported. Police have not released a possible motive in the killings.

The Times-Union newspaper quoted an unidentified woman on Facebook saying, "I can not fathom why anyone would want to hurt these two incredibly kind souls. You were truly a light of friendship, kindness and love, and you both genuinely restored a little faith to humanity in my heart."

Buda was remanded to the Dutchess County Justice and Transition Center in lieu of $500,000 cash bail or $1,000,000 bond.

https://www.facebook.com/DutchessCountySheriffsOffice/

Tags
New York, Murder, Police

© 2025 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More True Crime
Jammacar Rodkesh Gayle

Florida Man Steals Knife From Butcher Counter to Brutally Stab Woman Who Criticized His 'Uncontrolled' Children

Memphis Police

Pregnant Woman Was Ready to Apologize After Her Dog Bit a Child. Then Armed Teens Arrived to Beat Her With Guns

Texas Teen Bond_04142025_1

Mother of Teen Accused of Stabbing Rival Athlete Slams 'Lies' They Used Donations for Lavish Purchases: 'We Have Not Received a Single Dime'

Man Accused of Murdering Girlfriend Arrested While Being Investigated for

Man Accused of Murdering Girlfriend Arrested While Being Investigated for Another Woman's Death