Ohio Man Killed In Police Shootout Later Identified As Suspect in Decades-Old Cold Case Murder of Teen Girl

Deborah Miller was murdered in 1981 in her apartment

By
Deborah Miller
Deborah Miller was 18 when she was found murdered in her apartment. WYKC screenshot

A fatal police shootout led authorities to solve a 43-year-old Ohio mystery.

Police were serving James Vanest, 68, with an indictment on federal gun charges when he barricaded himself in a motel room and opened fire. One officer was shot in the arm, and Vanest was killed, according to the Associated Press.

DNA tests on Vanest later confirmed that he had murdered an 18-year-old woman 43 years ago, the AP reported.

Deborah Miller was murdered in 1981 in her apartment. Vanest was her upstairs neighbor at the time, WKYC-3 reported.

Police questioned Vanest in the case several times.

"Over the past 40 years, her (Miller) homicide has gone unsolved. During this time, the case has been reopened several times. One individual continued to draw investigators' attention, but not enough evidence could ever be provided to sustain an indictment," Mansfield Police Chief Jason Bammann during a press conference, according to the TV station.

The shootout with U.S. Marshals occurred Nov. 18. The station reported that Vanest fired multiple rounds and injured an officer before being shot by police.

"Today, this fugitive with an extensive violent criminal history dating back to the 1970's attempted to kill officers on scene during the arrest. Unfortunately, one officer was shot but all officers on scene responded with professionalism, commitment and dedication to safely resolve the situation," U.S. Marshal Pete Elliott statement, according to WKYC-3.

Tags
Murder, Murder investigation

© 2025 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More True Crime
Jammacar Rodkesh Gayle

Florida Man Steals Knife From Butcher Counter to Brutally Stab Woman Who Criticized His 'Uncontrolled' Children

Memphis Police

Pregnant Woman Was Ready to Apologize After Her Dog Bit a Child. Then Armed Teens Arrived to Beat Her With Guns

Texas Teen Bond_04142025_1

Mother of Teen Accused of Stabbing Rival Athlete Slams 'Lies' They Used Donations for Lavish Purchases: 'We Have Not Received a Single Dime'

Man Accused of Murdering Girlfriend Arrested While Being Investigated for

Man Accused of Murdering Girlfriend Arrested While Being Investigated for Another Woman's Death