Federal Judges Block SAVE Student Loan Plan
A significant setback occurred in the Biden administration's student debt relief efforts. Two judges from Kansas and Missouri have issued orders to freeze key portions of the Saving on a Valuable Education (SAVE) repayment plan. This decision directly impacts student borrowers across the nation.
The SAVE plan, a pillar of President Joe Biden's strategy to manage student debt, now faces legal challenges. Republican-led states have filed lawsuits, claiming that the executive branch exceeded its authority by implementing SAVE.
Details of Legal Intervention
The injunctions granted by the judges are preliminary. This means they are not permanent but will halt the plan's progress until further court proceedings. As a result, two aspects of the program have hit pause. First, the administration cannot cancel federal student debt for those in the program. Second, they cannot roll out new provisions concerning payment adjustments.
Before the injunction, the SAVE plan allowed enrolled borrowers to qualify for forgiveness after a decade of payments. The total debt forgiven under the plan has reached $5.5 billion, aiding 414,000 individuals.
Expected Payment Reductions Halted
Before the legal halt, the Biden administration planned to lower payments for millions of borrowers come July. Now, the future of these anticipated reductions remains uncertain. This hiccup could affect many who were expecting a financial reprieve.
SAVE's Generous Terms
The SAVE plan is notable for its preferential terms, especially for those with lower incomes. It connects monthly payment amounts to a borrower's income and number of dependents. To date, over 8 million people have enrolled. Astonishingly, 4.6 million of them have monthly payments set at zero dollars.
The program also offers a shorter pathway to debt relief than other income-based repayment plans. For instance, someone who has borrowed $12,000 or less can have their debt forgiven after making payments for just ten years. Each additional $1,000 borrowed extends the payment period by one year.
Additionally, the SAVE plan addresses the issue of accruing interest on small monthly payments. For those making a complete monthly payment, any unpaid interest doesn't accumulate. Suppose $50 in interest is due monthly, and the borrower's full required payment is just $30. In that case, the outstanding $20 interest would not be added to the loan balance.
ALSO READ: Biden Proposes to Ban Medical Debt in Consumer Credit Scores, Loan Decisions-Millions Could Benefit
Uncertain Times for Borrowers
While the lawsuit's merits are examined, borrowers enrolled in SAVE can stay the course. Their monthly payment amounts are not expected to fluctuate. However, other features of the plan could remain frozen if the legal dispute persists.
Planned provisions, such as reducing undergraduate loan payments from 10% to 5% of discretionary income, are now in jeopardy. Those with mixed undergraduate and graduate debts could also delay intended payment revisions.
The Lawsuits' Contentions
Two groups of states have launched separate but coinciding legal attacks on the SAVE plan. The complaint spearheaded by Kansas argues that the plan effectively turns loans into grants without congressional appropriation. They suggest this far exceeds the Department of Education's authority given by Congress in 1993.
Cost of the SAVE Plan
Financial impacts are at the forefront of the disputes. Depending on enrollment numbers, estimates put the cost of the SAVE program between $138 billion and $475 billion over the next decade. For comparison, Biden's earlier proposed student loan forgiveness initiative was set to cost around $400 billion.
With these legal challenges now materializing, the future of the SAVE plan is uncertain. Stakeholders, particularly the hundreds of thousands of affected borrowers, are closely watching how these court battles will unfold and shape the contours of student debt relief.
